![]() |
| View my take on the subject here |
Thoughts on a wide range of subjects relevant to my work as a Caribbean journalist.
The theme assigned the upcoming regional meeting of regional labour ministers in Guyana ambitiously focuses on “social justice” during what the International Labour Organization (ILO) proposes to be a discussion on “the foundation for a sustainable Caribbean transformation.”
I am not sure how such fanciful themes are brainstormed and finalised, but it must have been that somebody or bodies spent time on a host of stuffy texts which explore current thinking on notions of equity and justice as fundamental components of the solution to what the framers of the May 23-25 conversation describe as “plural crises” in the Caribbean.
They must have been reading every newspaper there is to read, and followed all the newscasts, social media posts, and the lamentations of writers, musicians, and artists. It would have also been necessary to sift hollow political polemic and sloganeering from lived experience and trauma.
There had to have been a battle against political incumbents who claim, “all is well” (“excellent”) and those who narrate tales of terminal decline - until their turn arrives and all is suddenly well and “excellent”.
There had to have been the backdrop of April’s crime and violence talks and the largely infertile menu of under-developed, whimsical prescriptions depictive of cluelessness of high order … in high places.
Few from among us would contend that “plural crises” is the stuff of hyperbole. That we indeed face a multiplicity of multi-faceted and rapid downhill journeys on carriages fixed to wobbly, decaying, disintegrating wheels.
Those of us who have decided to stay, physically and emotionally, are left with a task way beyond the limits of partisan desire - the alternatives being exile of different degrees and expression.
You can sense an absence of commitment from a distance. There is a willingness to initiate destruction at the onset of defeat. Chronic claims of victimhood as a salve for complicity. Sectional triumphalism and factional defeat when victory becomes elusive. A quick resort to active and passive exile – darts thrown from both safely afar and within the neighbourhood.
Plural crises indeed. Little time to find how we came to this. To trace a lineage of descent. To contemplate the joint enterprise of loss. Instead, a simple resort to blame and hopelessness.
In that light, does the ILO (and, by extension, its Caribbean partners) understand what they are really getting themselves into when they meet in Guyana next week? Perhaps. I have seen that in the concept note for the meeting that last year’s communique from the Caricom Summit is cited with reference to a “whole of government and society approach to recovery and resilience.”
This is a tall order in any context. Of the host country Guyana, for example, Caribbean economist, Marla Dukharan, reported recently: “Guyana is still the world's fastest growing economy, but has the lowest import cover and they are withdrawing as fast as they deposit into their Sovereign Wealth Fund.”
How will this be addressed within the context of a meeting of labour ministers all ostensibly committed to “priority attention to and investment in integrated policies and strategies to create decent jobs, extend social protection and facilitate just transitions”?
Where will T&T’s growing socio-economic divide feature in the discussion on “human-centric” economic recovery and the challenge of labour migration in key sectors? Add to that the role of inward migration in expanding opportunities in our labour market.
Importantly, as well, is the requirement of “just transitions” within the context of inevitable global economic change, and an unfolding climate crisis against which all discussions on Caribbean climate must be nuanced.
It is time national dialogues in our region move more firmly in the direction of these subjects that have a bearing on our future viability. I looked and looked again at what the ILO has in store for Caribbean governments next week and hope we take an appropriate cue with eyes set on issues that reach farther and wider than unstable, chaotic labour markets and interventions to stabilise them.
Our labour ministers in this region are routinely clustered among the least influential of Cabinet members. Quick, name three of them from any three Caricom countries including your own.
True, such meetings are not meant to resolve all the problems of the world. But they play a role in defining the nature and pace of change. Come away with a reinforced status quo, and you have reached nowhere, achieved nothing – whatever the fancy language.
Now that
COVID-19 has begun to fade into the background – though it has not completely
disappeared - we should not let too much time pass before convening an honest
retrospective on the country’s pandemic response.
This should be
designed to capture everything from the quality of official interventions to
civil, political, scientific, communication, and other areas of national
performance.
Of course,
there will always be difficulties associated with the mediation of such a
discourse, particularly since virtually all quarters of recognised authority
are known to have fallen short – however hard we all tried. The judiciary, I
believe, remained intact and independent.
The fact is
nobody really saw this coming in the way it eventually did. And, in the
process, every strength and every weakness of a country still in the transition
to full maturity lay exposed for all to see.
That said, show
me a country, small or large, that matched the challenge through public policy
and private action to the extent that the pandemic turned out to be, as some
impostors here continue to suggest - much ado about a relatively minor matter.
The purpose of
a full review in T&T would be to examine both the brittle and the strong
points of the institutions - formal and informal – that acted on our behalf,
however marginal or integral their actual roles.
In the process,
we are likely to discover as much beauty as the utterly repulsive. Some of the
latter has been chronicled right here on this page and expressed as privilege,
political opportunism, charlatanism, and a most cynical cleavage to myth and
untruth.
Such public
observations therefore disqualify me from a mediating role since there is no
possibility of a “middle ground” when close to 4,400 have died.
From the very
beginning when COVID-denial (“it’s just a bad flu”) barged onto the public
stage, to claims that pandemic measures here comprised a uniquely
disproportionate reaction (“the rest of the Americas remains open for
business”), to an assertion of ethnic favouritism, open promotion of
vaccine-hesitancy, to the suggestion that many who died would have died anyway.
There is much to consider along the way.
These are not
pleasant memories. They all pointed to a willingness by some, led by
opinion-leaders acting from the standpoint of personal privilege, to have the
country sacrifice what they considered to be lesser lives and livelihoods.
Today, even as
the significant dent sustained on the economy is being addressed (as is the
case almost everywhere), there is a narrative which purports failure while
hopefully envisaging consequential partisan fortune. This is matched and
outdone only by the parading of statistics on violent crime as a function of
political boastfulness.
It has to be that
we are afflicted with some kind of illness deeply embedded in our collective
psyche that’s destined to be far more fatal than the virus which overran the
globe.
Last week, a
few of us were remembering covert food-sharing escapades, mask-wearing habits,
“essential” workers and the media, vaccination certificates, pandemic elections
(there were several throughout the Caribbean), quarantine detentions, border
closures, the press conferences, wild parties ignored by the police, “private”
beaches, painful nasal swabs, who visited previously unexplored territory for
the vaccine, COVID-deniers who fell ill, and most sadly we remembered those who
died.
At least
informally, we have been conducting our own individual and communal reviews.
But it would be worthwhile for us as a country to conduct a clinical
examination of all that went right and the several areas in which we fell down
on the job.
It could be
that the university folks are already having a rigorous look – as is their
duty. Some of their professionals played particularly important roles in
drawing attention to mental health perils and the science behind the vaccines.
Others, not that much.
The Media
Institute of the Caribbean, with which I am aligned, initiated several
introspective journalistic reviews of what was happening on the public
communication front regionally. The Association of Caribbean Media Workers
frequently brought regional journalists together to catch up on the challenges
and published ‘Through the Pandemic – State of the Caribbean Media Report
2022.’
Seems as if the
sector in which I work (reviled and mocked as it is) admirably saw a role for
itself in leading an open and honest discussion on what went wrong, and what
went right.
In the process, we unearthed numerous areas of fault and fragility, and points of real strength and resilience. The rest of society needs to know how we really made it to this point.
It’s World Press Freedom Day today and it appears most people here don’t really care or understand what it’s all about. It also follows the observance, two days ago, of International Workers’ Day aka May Day.
Filipino journalist,
Juan Pablo Salud, established a connection on Monday when he posted to his
Facebook page: “One fact you don't hear very often is that writing is labour,
and writers - novelists, journalists, poets, essayists, playwrights,
screenwriters, songwriters, social media content creators … form part of the
workforce.
We are found in every
industry, every human endeavor since the dawn of civilization.”
This made me recall the
time when (as a reporter and trade union member) covering labour news, I turned
to a news editor and said of a planned union demonstration: “Shouldn’t we be
out there too?” – despite knowing intimately of the weaknesses and foibles of a
labour movement proceeding slothfully into the future, to the extent that today
it appears stuck in the tarpits of slow death.
Whatever the
appropriate response, I believe press freedom is intrinsically aligned to a
wide swathe of freedoms and human rights – conscientious commitments that distinguish
us from other animal groups.
Press freedom, as one
by-product of wider freedom of expression, plays a key role in ensuring that
other rights are the stuff of lived reality. This obtains even as we recognise that
all rights are for everyone.
These rights include the
full gamut of civil and political rights, alongside the economic, social and
cultural. It is impossible, or at least highly unlikely, to distinguish the
conditions conducive to one from the other without at the same time denying the
inalienability, universality, and indivisibility of such freedoms.
In countries such as
ours – the products of colonialism, slavery, and other forms of coercion – we
continually encounter the cognitive dissonance that emerges each time we speak
of asserting human rights. There is this endemic, quick resort to prohibition
and an absence of the habits of freedom.
There are also people
who despise the (admittedly imperfect) press and would bask in its demise over narratives
or perspectives being given time and space that are not in keeping with their
own.
Another group includes
those who do not appear to understand that press freedom implies the right of
audiences/consumers to seek out, access, and procure content. Press freedom,
therefore, is not only for the press.
All platforms can
occupy space under the expansive umbrella of free expression, but the discrete
elements (inclusive of amateur social media outputs in all their
manifestations) are not all the same and distinctions are deservedly made.
Press freedom makes
specific demands of mainstream, legacy media that do not necessarily extend to
less formal platforms – whatever the common legal and presumed ethical
obligations. This is, however, not to diminish the value of other channels.
The media’s validating
role is also key to addressing disinformation and propaganda couched as
independent news and information. Had things been different, considerable pandemic
progress would not have been realised.
These things are being
considered at a time when human rights and freedoms are being tested in
unprecedented ways.
In the Caribbean, for
instance, a scarcity of resources together with relatively weak social and
political institutions conspire to undermine the prospects for peaceful and equitable
growth and development.
Pandemic measures added
considerably to the already challenging situation. We also face violent crime
as a singularly critical threat to Caribbean civilisation, accompanied by an
inability to properly understand and to address it.
We have seemingly been
moving from one crisis to the next, and the implications for media practice at
times such as these are exceedingly difficult to negotiate.
US scholar Dr Courtney
C. Radsch, to whose research I have recently contributed, asserts: “When there
is a fast pivot or crisis, media become even more politicised, and other
institutions are affected in ways that put further pressure on independent
journalism both inside the country and in surrounding areas, as well as in
those that become migratory hosts.”
Additionally, in our
neck of the woods, the indispensable role of reliable news and information in
the achievement of even the most modest developmental aspirations is being undermined
by brittle media infrastructure, endemic mis and disinformation, and governance
systems that are distinctly opaque and unaccountable.
It has also not been
helpful that politicians and their surrogates increasingly employ subversive
tactics to undermine the credibility and value of independent journalism even
as they ironically do so at their own peril.
At stake are rights in
excess of those claimed by the media and journalists. We’d do well to remember
this.
(First published in the T&T Guardian on April 26, 2023)
I am almost certain that most governments were not sure
what they were getting themselves into when they delivered a 2020 mandate to
the UN Secretary-General to come up with a roadmap for advancing a “common
agenda” in response to “current and future (global) challenges.”
It had to be they did not countenance the explosive
implications of a revised order, or different way of doing business that cedes
power, privilege and responsibility to otherwise maginalised social, economic,
and political elements.
Today, three years after this instruction to the global
body, and the worst impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic, the war-mongering,
imperialist desire, self-destructive development planning, and even more of the
same old, same old remain firmly in place.
There in fact appears an even more intense devotion to the
status quo – even on the heels of pandemic devastation.
Significantly, last week’s release of a third policy brief
related to the “Common Agenda” mandate focuses ambitiously on youth participation
in the decision-making process.
The “glass ceiling” concept has, quite rightly, occupied
gender-aware spaces, but I can think of no other group – at least here in the
Caribbean – more marginalised by power dynamics than our young people.
Think of the processes in which youth are engaged to
convert ideas and dreams into tangible enterprises contributing to economic,
social, and cultural wealth. I see few prospects for change.
The blockages, you see, are not passive omissions of policy
and practice, but active borders policed by regulation, convention, and blatant
discrimination.
On more than one occasion, I have had the painful
displeasure of witnessing the deflating impacts of this phenomenon. I am sure
that you have receipts of your own. Young people – bright-eyed and bushy-tailed
– whipped into submission - seen but not heard, denied voice and opportunity.
The UN policy brief thoughtfully addresses some of these,
but almost entirely from the standpoint of official validation through a
process of so-called “empowerment.” “We” (who are in charge) should open doors
for “them.”
There is a presumption of dominance in keeping with status
quo dynamics when what is evidently needed is a revolution that turns our
realities on their heads and shakes … hard.
What is the fear behind stepping aside? I have advocated
for this for more rapid and relevant embrace of digitalisation in both the
private and public sectors – a change recognisably dragging on its bottom to
nowhere.
Come on. Stand aside, be prepared to offer advice based on
experience, and pass the assignment to digital natives who eat, drink, and
sleep such a boundaryless reality.
We have dinosaurs fixed on risk instead of young people who
are recognising opportunity.
The UN Secretary-General, António Guterres, in introducing
the brief surmised that “transformative changes will simply not be possible at
the scale required without the buy-in and contributions of a wide range of
actors. This is especially true of the 1.2 billion young people alive today.”
Sounds like we have heard it all before, right? I have …
like 50 years ago (minus the population figure).
I think the time has come for all of this to move from the
stage of official briefs to multi-stakeholder action.
Our Caribbean governments joined the call for change in
2020. The UN system has done some work. What have we done? What do we expect to
see come of this?
The painfully obvious through all this is that young people
have, as the UN SG suggests “become a driving force for societal change through
social mobilisation – pushing for climate action, seeking racial justice,
promoting gender equality and demanding dignity for all.”
Right here in T&T, youth initiative and creativity are
visible in music, art, and the employment of innovative technologies.
They are the ones who should be steering us through the
digitalisation of government and private enterprise. I have argued before that
an age ceiling should be set for experts leading the digitalisation processes.
Give me 30-year-old digital natives who ask all the
“foolish questions.” Who understand that downloadable forms represent nothing
new. That technological facades for manual back-ends are no longer fooling
anyone.
I also feel sorry for the 50 and 60 and 70 year old
politicians pronouncing authoritatively on needed prohibitions rather than the
exploitation of social media opportunity.
I regret, on behalf of them, the false expectation that
their own calls for a common agenda for change could countenance their own
demise. Sadly, I am almost certain they will resist this with all their might.
Today’s column ought to have been about the regional symposium on ‘Violence as a Public Health Issue – The Crime Challenge’ which ended yesterday.
But because of my early
deadline for submission of this, bungled arrangements for meaningful media
coverage, and the absence of essential background reading, I have chosen to resume
a discussion on converting our cultural assets into both wealth and social
wellness.
However, before I leave
the symposium alone (though I found the leaders’ roundtable … instructive), I
just want to make it clear I agree that criminal violence provides an
established path to public health crises. There is sufficient literature on
this to at least agree with the main principles.
The political
commentary on this particular point has, however, been so underdeveloped and near
irrelevant that it is advisable to pay attention almost solely to what real
experts say on the subject, based on a level of empiricism and scrupulous
study. This cannot be left to amateurs, whatever their own political, professional
or social status.
Calls for more guns,
application of emergency powers, hanging people, increasing penalties, eliminating
rights, blaming the media, and de facto vigilante civilian policing almost
routinely emerge as predictable creed in an environment in which wholesome
understanding of cause and effect is ignored or absent.
Now, therefore, for
something about which I know a little, and which is not entirely unrelated to
the above. Last weekend began for me on Saturday morning at Arnim’s Art
Galleria in Port of Spain with a viewing of ‘Memoirs: A Sonnylal Rambissoon
Retrospective Pt. 2’.
This is an exceedingly
valuable exhibition for anyone with an interest in a wide variety of artistic
media. Now, my saying so does not under any circumstance make me any kind of
expert connoisseur or reviewer. I am suggesting this as someone who has re-entered
the world of visual art following a decades-long hiatus.
The exhibition ends on
Friday but there is an upcoming lino block engraving workshop on the 29th
at the same venue which references Rambissoon’s woodcut prints.
After leaving Arnim’s
on Saturday, it was off to the Fine Art Market at Anchorage in Chaguaramas for
observance of World Art Day.
Let me tell you: some
of the best people in the world are artists. There I was with my phone scrolled
to my Instagram account and some of my own modest work. Former journalist,
Halcian Pierre, currently described as a “neo pop” artist was present with kind
feedback, along with almost everyone else I spoke with.
On location as well was
retired master broadcaster/communication professional, Percy Parker-Williams,
with his vast collection of new artistic work.
There was also
impressive young artist, Vanessa George, who claimed that a tabanca had driven
her to some fantastic work. There was a fabric designer, together with
sculptors, and work in oil, acrylic, watercolour, pens, wood, steel, concrete.
Having spent too much
time there, I had to rush back to UWI for yet another Department of Creative
and Festival Arts (DCFA) student music recital. Scores of young musicians,
beautiful music, an audience spread out on “the greens” at the Creative Arts
Centre in St Augustine.
All of this meant that
I could not make it to Naparima Bowl where a Jazz Festival had begun with names
like the phenomenal LeAndra accompanied by the National Steel Symphony
Orchestra, Chantal Esdelle and Moyenne, Solman, and Rellon Brown and Dominant
Seventh Jazz Band did their thing.
Anybody notice yet
where I am going with this? My longtime colleague and friend, Peter Ray Blood,
can rattle off perhaps another dozen events over the weekend that proved that many
people are choosing not to stay locked away and unexposed to the explosion of
creative power currently being unleashed nationally.
David Rudder and
Comrade BC Pires were all week hawking Gary Hector’s ‘Naked’ production. I
heard things went well. And, yes, there was more. Ask Peter. And there was also
the launch of Desperadoes’ new panyard.
Then, yesterday, even
as Caribbean politicians and experts dissected rampant criminal violence
throughout the region, I was at Nalis in Port of Spain helping cultural
anthropologist, dance master, and writer, Sat Balkaransingh launch a new
collection of poems.
I thought about all the
people in our small space who are missing out on much of this through both justifiable
and manipulated fear. But my mind has also been on all the others who have
chosen hope through the opportunity to witness creation rather than yielding to
the spectre of destruction.
In this small place,
people and things are both broken and made.
Follow current national, regional and international dynamics, even superficially, and you’d come across ubiquitous reference to “implementation deficits” as a risk factor in the transition of ideas into lived reality.
For instance, the climate crisis - especially relative to
our experiences as small island developing countries of the Caribbean - is
replete with instances in which the big countries that have contributed most to
the challenges posed by carbon emissions habitually renege on commitments to alleviate
the impacts of human-caused (anthropogenic) climate change.
Regionally, some obligations under the Revised Treaty of
Chaguaramas suffer at the hands of grand pronouncements not reaching the stage
of on-the-ground action in the respective member states. True, there is redress
through the Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) – set up to adjudicate on breaches
of the Treaty. But should it always come to this?
In any event, and as an aside, I am of the view that
insufficient use of the CCJ in its “original jurisdiction" to adjudicate
disputes over implementation of the Treaty has allowed significant breaches
including free movement of skills provisions, and the meaning of “single market”
conditions to pass unpunished.
On another occasion, I can speak specifically about Guyana’s
local content regulations in the energy sector and, in T&T, of official breaches
of acceptable practice when it comes to the free movement of regional skills.
The other arena in which we witness implementation deficits
is exemplified in the number of times stated good intentions are never
converted into consistent, effective actions.
To be fair, to speak of a deficit does not automatically reference
malicious intent, especially in this latter context. It is not that our leaders,
at all levels from national to community, do not mean well or simply do not
care.
This is how political parties get to power and stay there –
through demonstrations of good intent. People won’t vote for politicians who
say or suggest from the start that they do not plan to address a problem of violent
crime or minimise the impacts of a pandemic, for instance.
It is also fair to assume that people interested in wider
political or even communal support must first display a willingness to get
things done for the benefit of everyone. The problem arises when there is a gap
between ideas and full realisation of plans arising from such ideas.
There is a significant amount of literature that explores
the underpinnings of such deficits or shortfalls. I am however most convinced
by the assertion that in too many instances, process takes on a life of its own
and eventually overrides anticipated outcomes.
It cannot be, for example, that a severe shortage of fire
tenders in T&T has been ignored and categorised as a low priority. Additionally,
and for certain, this is not a belated realisation by everyone from the prime
minister to politicians across the aisle, to senior public servants, to
community leaders.
A few years ago, while examining the phenomenon, Lois
Parkes of the Caribbean Centre For Development Administration (CARICAD) identified
some key elements of a successful implementation process: The Idea, Leadership,
Research, Stakeholder Engagement, Conceptual Design, Approval, Project Planning
and Implementation, Team Development, and Strategic Communication.
While all of this cannot be denied as major benchmarks for the
success of projects, they at the same time prescribe processes already well
known to our legendary Caribbean bureaucracies. Sometimes a pothole
in the road simply needs to be filled with anything before something else
happens.
In a region where everything is a priority, people need to
simply get going on the immediate, apparent needs as a matter of urgency. For where
along Parkes’ continuum, for example, remains the acquisition of fire tenders
to address emergencies in T&T?
What do we tell the family of Zaya and Kemba Morris about
all this? On what were the minister, the permanent secretary, and the
fire-fighting hierarchy otherwise too busy or under-resourced to address this
important need? At what stage of the process?
When these people in leadership go home after a day at
work, on what tasks do they tell their families they were so busy? At what
stage of the process had been the procurement of fire tenders? Where on the
project spreadsheet was this priority issue? Where was the vigilance of civil
society and political activism – the “stakeholder engagement”?
There is a deficit in our implementation agenda that creates
a yawning chasm between initial realisation/idea and achievement of goals. It sometimes
proves to be deadly. Let’s fix this, please.
Strip the Privy Council ruling in the Jason Jones case down to one of its core principles and what emerges is a judicial admonition that pri...