Strip the Privy Council ruling in the Jason Jones case down to one of its core principles and what emerges is a judicial admonition that private, consensual, sexual conduct involving adults should not fall in the sphere of criminal law.
Though the ruling is quite readable on its own, legal folk can explain for the layman what the decision means for wider constitutional rights and their protection. For, there are further consequences linked to the supremacy of our constitution and the limits of parliamentary authority.
That the matter was prosecuted by a former, influential legislator once charged with providing enforcement support for the offending law, lends the latter point no small measure of irony.
But that’s a relatively minor, passing observation – not to be ignored, but not entirely devoid of meaning when it comes to the relationship between legislation and the constitution.
At the centre of all of this are the rights of the individual – a requirement now generally subsumed by the view that individual rights are somehow inferior to community standards and rights.
Former attorney-general Anand Ramlogan, who argued the case in favour of Jones, is quoted as saying: “Constitutional rights exist precisely because majorities are not always right.
“They ensure that the dignity and equality of every citizen are not left to the changing tides of public opinion."
I am certain that other eminent attorneys-general past and present have lectured on this at law classes: that the test of a democratic society has as much to do with accommodating the preferences of the majority as it is duty-bound to protect the rights of minority constituents.
Even as a mere layperson I am aware of the fact that such a realisation can have an impact on instances where prevailing public opinion – let’s say on the prevalence of violent crime and who might be collectively responsible for it – can sidestep a requirement to administer existing law (and regulation) in a fair, non-discriminatory, constitutional manner.
I remember some years ago suggesting that addressing the egregious anomaly of our Equal Opportunity Act on the exempted matter of “sexual preference or orientation” should eventually land us in a position where same-sex unions become recognised in accordance with broader constitutional rights.
Amendments discreetly proposed by members of at least one Equal Opportunity Commission (EOC) – which were strenuously opposed by some politicians- do not quite take us there, but addressing the explicit prohibition would have certainly been a step in the right direction.
Both Jones and several other advocates have signalled that the Privy Council ruling is itself insufficient to the cause of full recognition of all rights to all citizens. Resurrecting the EOC amendments, which I know exist, can be one such obligation.
From there, lawful same-sex unions can be logically pursued – however mighty the hate agenda actively engaged by those horrified by mere mention of such a prospect. Some apprehension and fear have however been expressed even by vocal advocates for recognition of LGBTQI equal (not exclusive or special) rights.
I remember discussing this with a leading advocate here some years ago who felt a campaign for equal rights can be undermined by what they considered to be the distraction of a call for recognition of same-sex marriage.
Reading Jamaica’s Maurice Tomlinson on the Privy Council ruling reminded me of this when he argued that some regional advocacy groups did not appear confident about constitutional challenges to their anti-buggery laws and appeared lukewarm or diffident regarding his own efforts.
Back in 2016, the Jamaican advocate had taken T&T and Belize to the CCJ arguing that exclusion of “homosexuals” under our respective immigration laws went against the free movement provisions of the Revised Treaty of Chaguaramas. He lost the case partially on the grounds that the provision had caused no actual harm to anyone.
The Jones ruling, in my view, suggests that the very existence of such provisions can be harmful in its own right.
This is tough work. But committed allies, other human rights defenders, and enlightened advocates need to come on board. The Jones victory means much more than partially disempowering an active hate agenda. It signals possibilities that should yield greater confidence and pride.

No comments:
Post a Comment